When I was fifteen, I fell in love with a girl, well, two girls, actually. It was my first hardcore girl on girl crush, my first head over heels experience with the same sex, and my first heartbreak. Ah, the bittersweet tang of puppy love — there’s nothing quite like it, is there?
I was spending the summer at an all girls’ university half a country away from anyone I knew. I was all long legs and budding breasts, and still amused when men were unable to look me in the eye when they spoke to me. I thought I knew all there was to know about boys — I had all the boys at school twisted around my little finger. But despite all the rumors flying around about my high school roommate and I (that we were lovers — we weren’t…not yet) I didn’t know a damn thing about girls.
The first crush was much older than me — she was actually one of my instructors. A math major at Harvard, she was brilliant, witty, clever and I thought she was gorgeous. I’d never really felt anything for another girl, especially not one like her. She was what I would now describe as a butch, short boyish hair, ironic t-shirts tucked into the waist of her jeans, slim hips. I was in awe of her, of her worldiness, of her intellect. I wanted to be her, I wanted to be with her. She was my mentor in so many things, guiding me through the awkward stages of adolescence, introducing me to a world that I never knew existed, one of literature, travel, and exploration.
The other girl was closer to me in age, bisexual, though I didn’t find that out until later. She was worlds above me in experience, fully aware of her sexuality and fully aware of the power she wielded. Slim with short curly hair, she delighted in toying with her sexuality. Lowslung men’s jeans with a ratty t-shirt and sneakers one day, a delicate floral sundress with sculpted heels the next –she was a mercurial chimera. I was in awe of her, stuttering and stumbling over my words when she spoke to me. I remember the clear bell-like trill of her laugh, the feel of her arm against mine. The smell of her skin, and the huskier notes in her voice when she whispered in my ear. I wasn’t the only one in love with her — there was anothe girl, much closer to her. They’d grown up together, were from the same hometown, and anyone who saw them could see the devotion of the other girl. She was like a faithful puppy following her master to the ends of the earth.
It never went any further than that, not for me, not that summer. I was too shy to do anything more than flirt. I was all talk, hot air and bravado — my insides quivering at the feel of her arm around me. The older one went on to graduate from Harvard — she and I remained in contact for years, a mentor to my naivete, and she became a good friend, guiding me through a complicated affair. The other girl broke my heart, though not nearly as badly as she broke her friend’s heart. I wasn’t the one who found out about the older Navy boyfriend who took her virginity on the eighth green of a local golf course. I wasn’t the one who had also fooled around with her on the same golf course, wasn’t the one who was completely devastated, and wasn’t the one who went home early that summer.
I went home that summer changed, a little older and a little wiser. I’d learned something about myself and something about the nature of love and relationships, and that it didn’t matter who you fell in love with, whether they were a girl or a boy, that the heartbreak was still the same, the heartache just as bitter, and the rewards just as sweet.








5 Comments
I am always fascinated by these early experiences and the way that they shape our lives. Although often bitter-sweet, we learned from them. I loved this beautifully written piece.
I remember those first crushes, so interesting to have someone share theirs, thank you.
I love posts like this, I love story telling. I think we all have at least one story like this, describing the clumsiness of early sexuality… ahh the thrills..
This was a really good post.
It reminded me of my first infatuation with a girl a little bit. I can really relate with the feelings you felt. Except I acted on mine and while I didn’t end up heartbroken, it didn’t go so well. I did learn from it and it saved me quite a bit of trouble in terms of making future mistakes.
Thanks for sharing this. I always find it interesting to read about events that shaped things, whether they were small or large.
XoXo
What a gorgeous recollection. I love how well you can put your own feelings into our hearts.